Discipline in the Car

Question:

Do you have any advice on how to handle discipline while in the car, particularly when siblings fight? As I see it, the options are limited. Time out can't be used. I try to prevent problems by making sure each child has his own entertainment (CDs, books, etc.) Also, I try to remember to have a discussion with the children before we leave as to what behavior is expected. Pulling over to the side of the road sometime helps for a short time, but it's not always practical to be pulling over multiple times and traffic conditions may not allow it. Help!

Answer:

Pulling over is really the best answer. Did you read about that in one of the Positive Discipline books? I will go over the keys that make pulling over effective.

1. You say it isn't always practical. Actually it is very practical; it just isn't convenient. Raising children (and taking time for training) is often inconvenient, but it is essential to get the long term results we want with out children.
2. You also say it works some times for a short time. Pulling over some times and not others is the worst thing you can do to reinforce inappropriate behavior. When you pull over some times and not others, children get confused. They can't trust you to say what you mean and mean what you say. They learn to push for reactions. I promise that if you pull over a few times, consistently, you won't have to keep doing it because you have taught your children that you mean what you say. (More about this later.)
3. I'm guessing that the reason you think it is not practical is because (besides being inconvenient) it takes time and often causes lateness. Sometimes parents have to choose between being on time and taking time for training that is effective long term.
4. So, during a calm time (perhaps during a family meeting), let your children know in advance that you will pull over if they fight and that you will start driving again as soon as the BOTH let you know they are ready to drive again. Ask, "What is your understanding of what I'm going to do when you fight?" Wait until they have both told you. Clarify if there is any misunderstanding. Then ask, "How will I know when you are ready for me to start driving again?" Wait until they both acknowledge that you need to hear it from both of them. Now you know they have heard you and that they understand what you are going to do.
5. During the training period, purposely leave 10 minutes early. As soon as they start to fight, pull over – even if it is inconvenient.
6. MAGIC KEYS!!!
a. When you pull over do not say a word. When you use words, you give your children ammunition to defeat you. They understand actions better than words.
b. Be prepared with a good book to read. Quietly read it and ignore the fighting. The fighting will probably get worse before it gets better because they are trying to get you to respond the way you usually do.
c. Do not remind or lecture. It is disrespectful to assume they didn't hear you when you told them what you were going to do.
d. If you remain quiet, eventually they will get bored sitting on the side of the road. Wait until they both tell you are ready. When they do, say, "Thank you, and start driving again.
Hundreds of parents have tried this method. They all report the same thing. After about three times of consistently pulling over (five times at the most), children stop testing because they know they can trust their parent to do what he or she said she will do. Then when they start to fight, all you have to do is start to pull over and they will say, "Okay, we'll stop." I hope you will join the hundreds of parents who have found this effective when they use all the guidelines. My best to you, Jane Nelsen